The ECP has undergone a major revamp of late, with new restaurants popping up like mushrooms after spring rain. A new dining cluster has even sprung up at the old Big Splash. So on serendipitous, spontaneous Sat evening, Mr Cool Jim (Bean) and myself decided to play epicurean at the East Coast Beach, and settled at Scruffy Murphy's Irish Pub to kick back, relax and eat some really good food. Scuffy Murph is one of the Irish pubs under the Gaelic Inns family.
Scruffy Murphy's has the quintessential "drinking hole around your hood" kind of laid back charm. At that rather early dinner hour of 8-ish, families were the main crowd, although as the night progressed, the crowd gets more "Saturday beer buddy chill out. Scruffy Murphy's has an extensive and completely transfat-laded all-day breakfast of essentially different permutations of fry-ups. The rest of the menu while extensive, was an unexciting rendition of pub food. I decided on their chef's recommendation of fish & chips (Cream Dory in a Kilkenny Ale batter) while Mr Cool Jim (Bean), had the traditional English Sunday lunch of roast beef with Yorkshire pudding.
When me eyes first fell on the fish & chips, I knew it was over-done. The fish was not evenly fried and had patches of brown dry biscuit-like batter around it. The dory itself was fishy, fishy, fishy. It tasted as if it was bred in vile drain water. The only slight saving grace was the lovely sourish tannic malt vinegar, which I sprinkled generously to mask the bad fishy taste. The dory was velvety-textured, although that did nothing to save the dish. And the portions was not generous. For me, they have violated the cardinal rule of fish & chips - freshness. Although the fish is deep-fried in batter, that should never be an excuse to compromise on freshness. In comparison, the fish & chips I had at Sunset Grill earlier in the week beats this rendition hands and legs down.
Mr Cool Jim (Bean)'s roast beef was much more palatable. The beef was nicely flavoured, although it was too well done for my liking. The Yorkshire pudding has an interesting chewy texture, but was a tad bland and somewhat dry. It definitely fell short of my expectations, especially as traditional Yorkshire puddings are usually baked underneath a roasting rack of meat to catch the fats and render it ah-all-so-sinful. The service was good, homely and prompt, with cute waitresses in little denim shorts. Given that this is a Irish pub, where understandably, the focus is not on its food, culinary blips like these can be somewhat, with one eye half-open and the other eye closed, forgiven. Nevertheless, if I ever do go back to Scruffy Murph's again, I'll be sure to skip the food and stick to my trusty mug of ice-cold Kilkenny.
Muddy Murphy's Irish Pub
1000 East Coast Parkway, B7 Marine Cove, Tel: 6449 7717
Food - 4.9 / 10
Location & Parking - 6.5 / 10 Lots at ECP are not easy to find on weekend nights. A stake-out is usually needed
Service 6.9 / 10
Bang for the buck (value for money) - 2 out of 5 Mama Tang's thumbs up.